Where can I get a key made without wasting a trip?

47 years of hands-on Baltimore-area locksmith experience under Maryland Locksmith License #0010. Here is the operator’s take on where can i get a key made.

Where can you get a key made in Baltimore?

If you’re asking where can i get a key made, you’ve got more options than most people think. In Baltimore, a basic house key can usually be copied at a locksmith shop, some hardware stores, a few home centers, and even some grocery store kiosks. But the real question is whether you need a copy or a key that actually works the way the original did.

For a plain Schlage or Yale house key, a fast copy is usually fine if the original isn’t badly worn. For Medeco, restricted keys, or older cylinders that have seen better days, I’d want to look at the lock itself. A key cut from a bad original is still a bad key. That happens a lot in rowhomes in Canton, Parkville, and toward Towson, where the lock is older than the person asking for the copy.

Most folks don’t realize that the machine is only part of the job. The operator matters. You need someone who can spot a shallow cut, a bent blade, or a head that’s cracking before the copy goes out the door. If you want the residential side of this broken down further, I’ve got a related guide on our residential locksmith services page.

And if you’re standing there with a key that already sticks or skips in the cylinder, don’t assume you just need another copy. Sometimes you need the lock checked, not the key duplicated.

What happens when a locksmith makes your key?

On a service call, I start by looking at the original key and the lock it’s supposed to run. That sounds simple, but it saves a lot of bad copies. If the original has rounded peaks, uneven pin chambers from wear, or a twist in the blade, I’ll usually tell you that copying it as-is is a gamble.

Here’s the thing: a proper key cut is not just “duplicate and go.” We check the blank, match the keyway, and make sure the shoulder depth and cuts are right for the cylinder. On some doors, especially older Baltimore rowhomes, I’ll check strike alignment too, because a key that seems “bad” is sometimes fighting a sticky bolt-work issue instead.

If the key is for a deadbolt, I want the bolt fully extended and retracted a few times. If the key is for a knob lock, I’m listening for spring tension that feels wrong or a cylinder that’s starting to bind. Those little things tell me whether the key is the problem or the lock is drifting out of spec.

Honestly, the part nobody mentions is that a locksmith is often reading the wear pattern before the machine even turns on. That’s why a shop copy and a field copy can come out different, even with the same blank.

How much does a key copy usually cost?

For a basic house key, you’ll usually see something in the low single-digit to low teens range at a hardware store, and a locksmith shop may charge a little more depending on the blank and the time involved. If you need a standard deadbolt rekey or a key made from code, the total can move into the roughly $20 to $40 range for simple work, and more if the lock needs service.

Don’t compare that to a deadbolt replacement, though. A basic deadbolt itself is usually around a $40 industry-standard part before labor, and that’s a different job from making a key. If the cylinder is worn, the key copy might be cheap and still not solve the problem. That’s why I ask what the lock is doing, not just what the key looks like.

For higher-security brands like Medeco, the cost depends on whether the key is restricted and whether proof of authorization is needed. Those jobs are usually more expensive than a plain Schlage copy, and they should be. You’re paying for the keyway, the blank, and the control behind it.

So if somebody tells you every key should be the same price, that’s just not how the trade works. The blank, the lock, and the condition of the original all change the number.

Why do some keys not copy cleanly?

Most of the bad copies I see come from one of four problems. First, the original key is worn down from years of use. Second, the blank is wrong or low quality. Third, the lock itself is worn enough that a perfect copy still won’t feel right. Fourth, the key has been duplicated so many times that the cuts have drifted off shape.

That last one happens more than people think. A key copied from a copy tends to lose accuracy a little at a time. After a few generations, the shoulders don’t sit right and the tip starts to ride low or high in the pin stack. Then you get a key that almost works. Almost is not good enough when you’re standing at the front door in the rain.

I also see trouble with keys for older Liberty, Cannon, and other safe locks when the dial has drift or the bolt-work is stiff. Different problem, same symptom: the key or combination feels wrong because the mechanism is worn, not because the cut is “mystery bad.”

Is the key really the issue? Usually, but not always. If the lock has relockers triggered, bent parts, or a bad core, making another copy just gives you another bad result. That’s why I check the lock before I blame the key.

Should you copy the key yourself or call a pro?

If it’s a plain house key and you’ve got a clean original, a kiosk or hardware store copy can be fine. If you need one spare for a back door or utility room, that’s usually a simple job. But if the key is for your main entry, a high-security lock, or a door that already sticks, I’d call a locksmith.

Why? Because the cheap copy saves nothing if it fails when you need it. I see this on emergency calls in Baltimore County and down into Maryland suburbs all the time. Someone made a quick copy for convenience, then the door started hanging up because the lock was out of alignment or the original was already too worn to duplicate accurately. Now you’ve got a lockout and a bad key.

There’s also a safety angle. If a key is for a secure side door, a rental, or a home with restricted hardware, you want the right blank and the right authorization. A locksmith can also rekey the cylinder if the old key has been lost or shared too widely. That’s where a cylinder rekey makes more sense than another copy.

One more thing: if you’re unsure, bring the key in before you leave. Ten minutes at the shop beats a wasted trip back across town.

What makes Easter’s different for key making?

We’ve been doing this since 1953, and that matters because key work is usually about noticing the small stuff before it becomes a lockout. Easter’s holds Maryland Locksmith License #0010, issued in 2004; the family business goes back to 1953. That license date tells you when the state started regulating the trade, not when we started working on locks.

When you call us, we don’t just grab a blank and hope. We look at the keyway, the lock condition, and whether the copy should be cut by code, by sample, or by the lock itself. That’s especially useful when you’re dealing with a worn front door in Baltimore, a side entry in Washington, DC, or a rental turnover in Northern Virginia or Pennsylvania.

We also know the difference between service and sales. We service Liberty, Cannon, Browning, Sentry, Fort Knox, and Winchester safes, but the only safe we currently sell is the Winchester Bandit #3. If your question turns from a simple key copy into safe work or a stuck lock, we can tell you quickly whether it’s a key issue, a core swap, or a bigger mechanical problem.

And if the lock is far enough gone that a fresh key won’t help, we’ll say so. That saves time, and it keeps you from paying for a copy that never had a chance.

Frequently Asked Questions